So, Cocoon

Oct. 8th, 2005 09:51 pm
forsyth: (GG ID)
My sister got my mom Cocoon, so we watched it. It's a good movie. But I realized something as I was watching it. It's not a science-fiction movie. Oh, it has aliens, and the UFO at the end, but that's just window dressing.

They're not aliens. They're angels. I mean, look at it. They come from the sky, they're immortal, they can restore health, they glow, they fly, and strike people stupid when they're seen in their true forms. Same qualities as people ascribe to angels.

It's Sci-fi window dressing on a movie about angels coming down and healing old people, then lifting them up the heaven. Or them dying. Because, for practical purposes, they're dead. The ending sequence where the minister's talking is supposed to be reassuring, they're not really dead, they're off to live forever in space! Which is functionally different than being dead... how, exactly, since they're not around, and they can't come back to Earth ever? it doesn't matter if they're dead, abducted by aliens, or raptured up on wings of light, it all has the same effect. Which is one of the things that's been mentioned on Slacktivist's reviews of the atrocious Left Behind books.

The movie works because it focuses on the reactions and interactions of the humans, the aliens are just sorta there. Only two of them even speak. They're not the point of the story, they're just macguffins. The movie's not about them.

It struck me especially when all the people in the special features my parents were watching kept referring to it as a sci-fi movie. I wonder if they didn't really notice, or just figured it made people more comfortable and made it more accessible than a movie specifically about angels. Which is probably part of why there's so much about aliens in most new agey stuff, they can have all the same attributes as angels, but with the serial numbers filed off. None of the baggage of organized religion, but the same warm fuzzies. Which always makes me wonder what a angel's job description actually IS.
forsyth: (Default)
"Wankers, the lot of them."

"Who?" the buddha asked.

"Y'know, you seem awfully attached to my scooty chair, for all that it's an illusion. I thought you'd buggered off to somewhere else."

"We're British tonight?"

"The British have better profanity. All we've got is damn, and then your bog standard anglo-saxon terms referring to sex or poop, and yes, I KNOW what the British words mean. But they sound better, and aren't offensive to Americans, because they're not part of our culture. Sorta like how the British were weirded out when Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me opened over there."

"So we are British then."

"No, we are just fanboy. I blame Monty Python and Terry Pratchett. And probably Neil Gaiman, but I don't want to mess with him, he's got a satanic tomato."

"It's only a model. So which wankers roused your ire?"

I flopped down on my bed, on top of the pile of shorts. It's already starting to get chilly, and I just unpacked them. That's planning, that is. "Oh, 'literary' authors. Seriously, they write books that are about wannabe writers, and OMG TEH DRAMA, and then the character in the book meets some amazing chick and things go either good or bad, and Great Lessons Are Learned. Or similar dibble. It's like Real Life Self-Insertion Fanfic."

The buddha didn't say anything, but I'd gotten rolling, so I went. "I mean, seriously, you want to whine about your life and bitch about drama? Get an LJ, that's what they're for. Many of the novels would fit right in as LJ posts. And hey, they'd save a few trees that way. But I can't really blame them. Well, yet, anyway. The real culprits are the teachers who repeat crap like 'Write what you know!' over and over again, without mentioning things like 'Go and do something interesting.' And the ones who bash anything 'genre' as addlepated fluff. When they're told to write what they know, and all they know is being an underemployed wannabe writer, what else are they supposed to write about? All that creativity wasted. Oh, but hey, it's Real Life! It's Serious! It's got Great Human Emotions and Deep Meaning. Whoop-dee-doo. You can have Great Emotion and Deep Meaning and still have spaceships or dragons or guys in tights punching each other. But that's not 'Serious' literature. PAH! And of course, the kids they've trained grow up to become the next generation of gatekeepers of Literature with a capital L. And the cycle repeats itself."

The buddha spun quietly in my chair for a second. "Are you finished?"

"I could go on, but I think you get the point. Trust me, I could go on."

"So how much of that isn't sour grapes?"

"Bah," I said, "As you Californians would say, 'Whatever.'"

"Well, if people are buying it, what's your problem with it? If they're enjoying it, and the readers enjoy it, how's it hurt you?"

"Because they keep up this facade of what makes something 'Real Literature', and sneer at anything that doesn't meet their standards."

"Ah. Completely unlike what you're doing, then."

Unconcerned by my glare, he started trimming his toenails. "Do you show up just to annoy me?" I asked.

"If you just want comfort food, ask a fairy godmother. You wanted an imaginary spirit guide debate."

I sat up. "Yeah, but shouldn't you be trying to help? Infinite compassion and all that."

He leaned back in the chair. The chair's not set up to DO that, damnit. I wish it could. "Hey, I've got compassion. I totally feel your pain. Infinitely."

"That's because you live in my head."

"Bingo. But the other part of the whole Buddha thing you're forgetting. Infinite patience. I've got nowhere important to be. Nirvana's not going anywhere. Besides, time's just another illusion. So yeah, I feel your pain, but I'm not gonna kick your ass into gear. Even if I could. That's your job."

"That is almost entirely unhelpful."

"Ah, but only almost! I can only show you the door, you're the one that has to walk through it."

"That worked out so well for Neo."

"He got a cookie out of it. And phenomenal cosmic powers."

"And he got killed, then brought back for a pair of bad sequels."

"He got the chick."

I held up a hand to stop him. "And then SHE died. Twice. And what's with stories always rewarding the hero with nookie, anyway? Even stories for kids. Go out, kill something, get laid. There's a very caveman vibe about the whole thing..."

"We're wandering from the subject again."

"Not really, I think we've said all there is to say about it right now."

"So you're going to get to work?"

"No, I'm going to bed. Have you looked at the clock?"

"Time's an illusion, remember?"

"Fine, but I still have the illusion of Arabic class tomorrow afternoon, and I'd like to be up BEFORE five minutes before class."

"Sleep is for the weak and unenlightened."

That's me to a T. At least at this hour of the morning.


Things Wot Come Before:
Stories from the Rabbit Hole
Stories from the Rabbit Hole, Part 2
There's a Buddha on My Bed
A Discussion of Procrastination and Buddhism
Buddhablog
Haven't Seen Him in a While
The Illusion of Pain
Stuff that Binds
The Joy of Scrubdom
More About Failure


Tags: Rabbit Hole, Mindscribbles, Religion, Movies
forsyth: (Politics Icon)
One of a large subset, obviously.

But in this case, it's this. Why is somebody as "having faith" or "being faithful" always presented as a good thing? Like they're somehow better than other people, just because they say they're religious. Like, oh, say, Pat Robertson, who's manifestly batshit insane, and yet, the media tiptoes around it because he's a minister. Or how Bush is presented as "faithful" while he's lying to the country and bombing thousands of Iraqi civilians.

Why can lying, corrupt, weasly assholes get free points for being "faithful"? If there's anything we should have learned from the Godfather movies, it's that going through the motions of religion doesn't make somebody nice. And if there's something we should have learned from, oh, I dunno, the Inquisition, terrorists, and so on, it's that even when people really believe religion, they can STILL be batshit insane, and they can make the religion encourage them to be batshit insane.

I imagine a lot of it's usually due to the fact that the people making the loudest protestations of faith are making sure they do it in the faith of the biggest group of the area. Which gives them the dual benefit of "see, he's like us," and the reverence usually inspired by being brought up in that religion. And often, the people who'd notice that the person's really an asshole, and not vote for them aren't going to go out and start saying "X isn't really a (whatever)." Because that's a bad idea in general, and usually plays into the hands of people who like to divide people. And the people who really follow the religion tend to try to live up to things like "judge not, lest ye be judged" and so on, I guess.

But it's really annoying. And doesn't help the country. So, just to repeat, Pat Robertson is a dangerous fundamentalist Republican leader.

Of course, if you listen to the "news", you'll get the impression that wherever you go, Christianity is under attack in the US. Right. With what, 75% of the country self-identifying as Christian? Sure. Uh huh. Right.

And, last but not least in this rambling stream of consciousness, a link. Polls on American Religious Tolerance at www.religioustolerance.org. The important poll is about halfway down, the Gallup one about whether or not people would vote for a President who was X. Last poll was in 1999, and is broadly good news (though I suspect that at least some people would answer differently to a poll taker than they would at the voting box) In last place though, are atheists. With, admittedly, 49%, a lot better than in 1959.

Technorati Tags: Politics, Religion, Mindscribbles, Rants
forsyth: (Politics Icon)
Okay, seriously. What. The. Fuck. Pat Robertson said we should assassinate Hugo Chavez, the elected president of Venezuela.

I am far less shocked by that than I should be. Must be from reading too much about the 80s, when we were knocking over elected South American governments like they were dominoes.

But, seriously. Folks. We are the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. You know that big list of Things Not To Do? The one with Torture on it? Yeah, assassinating elected officials in other countries is on it too. Seriously, the Republican leadership no longer has any connection to what America actually means. (And let's not even bother with the "thou shalt not kill" thing, that's long since gone.)

And as always, Jon Stewart has the goods.

Technorati Tags: WTF?, Evil, Crazies, Politics, Religion, Daily Show
forsyth: (GG ID)
Why do Christian fundamentalists make a big stink about trying to post the Ten Commandments everywhere? Aren't they supposed to be followers of Jesus Christ, thus the name? So why don't they go around demanding posting stuff from the New Testament, or things Jesus said? Like oh, I dunno. "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." "Love thy neighbor as yourself." "Judge not, lest ye be judged." etc.

(And yes, I know the answer for some of them is that they're batshit insane death cultists who want to bring about the end of the world. But what about the rest?)

Technorati Tags: Religion, Mindscribbles
forsyth: (GG ID)
"WASHINGTON -- President Bush said Monday he believes schools should discuss "intelligent design" alongside evolution when teaching students about the creation of life."

Okay, look. Intelligent Design isn't a scientific theory. It doesn't offer anything that can be proved or disproved, doesn't make any predictions. And it doesn't help us understand anything better. It's watered-down Creationism, with all the references to God removed so they can pretend it's not religious. Basically, ID says "Life is too complicated to have evolved on its own, at least portions must have been designed." (There's also, I suppose, a splinter group that doesn't actually disagree with evolution, and says that God designed the universe, including its rules, and created life by those rules). But there's a problem with Intelligent Design. A very simple, and fundamental one. If something's designed, it implies a designer. Now, Creationists could just say "God did it", but by pretending to not be about religion, ID proponents can't do that, they just leave the Designer unspecified. It could be God, or aliens, or interdimensional mice. But with the exception of claiming God Did It, the next obvious question is where did these Designers come from? If life couldn't appear on its own, and had to be designed, then who designed the aliens? And who designed the designers of the aliens, and then it's turtles all the way down.

So don't let their protests fool you, Intelligent Design is just Creationism all over again, and dishonest Creationism at that. Or it's such a weak version that it doesn't disagree with evolution anyway. But either way, it's not science and doesn't add anything to science classes, aside from giving the teacher a chance to go "And here's why this isn't science." Science depends on things that can be tested and reproduced, and make predictions that can be tested. "Intelligent Design" does none of these.

And it really shouldn't surprise anybody at this point that Bush would push it to fire up his base.

(via Obsidian Wings, see also this New Yorker article and many many other places on the Internets.)

Technorati Tags: SCIENCE!, Religion, Rants, WTF?, Politics
forsyth: (GG ID)
Y'know, somehow I doubt most of the people who look at the Muslim world today, and try and place the blame on Islam would place the blame for how much most of Europe sucked during the Dark Ages on Christianity.

Not to say that the current varieties of religion in either case can't be part of the problem, but there's a lot more screwed up in the Middle East than religion. And there was a lot more screwed up in Dark Ages Europe besides the Catholic church.

Technorati Tags: Mindscribbles, Politics, Religion
forsyth: (GG ID)
Another thing that struck me, when reading through some more Buddhist stuff, along with a couple other things, that I just don't get. The whole idea of "Don't do X while you're alive, then when you die, you'll go to a paradise where you can do X even better!" It's usually about sex, or drinking, and just confuses me. You get rewarded by resisting sex/drink/whatever by... being given sex/drink/whatever. Seems kinda counterintuitive, I guess.

Technorati Tags: Religion, Mindscribbles

On Magic

Jul. 3rd, 2005 08:44 pm
forsyth: (Default)
"Correlation is not causation."

I don't believe in magic, I should state that right up front. I waver between the outright "Nah, that doesn't work" and a more Han Soloish "Haven't seen anything to convince me" point (though I'll admit, I haven't seen that many strange things in my time, the problem of being a boring American geek, rather than an interstellar smuggler). This despite my abiding love for Mage, and that magic could in many ways make the world cooler. I'm relatively sure this statement didn't surprise any of you.

But on the other hand, I think that spells and such can work, after a sort. Not so much on them influencing the universe, but influencing you. You being the hypothetical magic-user. You're not going to be able to summon up a million dollars, or wish for a dozen models, or anything like that, at least not and have it work. Not gonna be summoning up demons to smite your enemies, none of that. But that's not how most non-fantasy (fantasy fantasy or fundamentalist wingnut fantasy) "spells" are presented, anyway. Small effects and coincidence is more their domain. And that sorta works.

You whip up a ritual to get a better job, you're going to be paying more attention to opportunities, and (probably) going to be more attentive at work, which combine to make you more likely to find and take opportunities that show up. Love potions, as the witch in one of Neil Gaiman's Endless stories in Endless Nights, just give somebody the courage to make the first move when they otherwise wouldn't have. And so on. The repetition and ritual focus your attention on the thing you want, so you pay more attention to it, and opportunities, and more ready to take risks. It's the same kind of thing as self-help books that suggest you write down your goal X times a day, it keeps the thing you're looking for in the front of your mind, occupying a little bit of your attention, and waiting to grab all of your attention when it matters.

Of course, if you don't look, or try, and just figure it's taken care of, the "spell" won't work. It's like the old fable, the gods help those who help themselves. Also, people tend to put a lot more weight on unusual occurances than everyday ones, so if the spell "works", you're going to remember that more than the dozens of times you tried something and nothing happened.

I suspect, in my heathen ways, that similar reasoning applies for the people who pray regularly asking God for stuff. Did I mention the plethora of "Christian Inspiration" books back by the music section at work, and how many are by Falwell, Dobson, the Left Behind guys, and similar? Plus all the "Pray yourself thin" and similar self help books. The New Age section isn't far away, with it's own goofy self-help and "inspirational" stuff. And then there's just the regular self-help and "inspirational" sections too. How neurotic ARE we Americans, anyway?

Technorati Tags: Mindscribbles, Religion, Me, SCIENCE!, Life, The Universe, and Everything
forsyth: (GG ID)
"Are you sure that's what you want to call it? You must know some of your friends will take it entirely wrong."

I stood in the center of my room and shrugged. "That's half the fun," I said, "Besides, they all know I'm boring and any title like that is going to be just innuendo. Until one day I decide to link to a sex toy store or something, just to see them react."

The buddha spun lazily in my computer chair. "Huh," he said.

"I have way too much crap."

"Coming around to the idea that possessions cause desire which causes suffering?" he asked.

"No, not really. I just mean that I can't see half the floor in my room. And there's hundreds of books on my shelves I haven't read. Not really a spiritual angle at all. If anything, it's the opposite, because all the stuff is keeping me from making more connections with people, the kind that matter. Because there's a lot of it, and it can't be easily moved. And then there's the opportunity costs of it, too. Even with my old discount, and buying things at used bookstores, how much did those couple shelves of RPG books cost me? Games I've never run, never played in, hell, a bunch of the books I haven't even read. At all. Or the shelf of graphic novels, and the boxes of comics. I haven't pulled anything out of the comic boxes in months. And the random computer games. What else could I have spent that money on? School? Moving? Pornography?"

"You have the internet, free pornography abounds there."

"Okay, bad example. Travel. Maybe I've just done too much RPGs and fantasy stuff, but I keep thinking about traveling. Just wandering."

He stood up. "It's not nearly so romantic as it's made out to be. Especially when all you've got is a robe and a bowl. Spiritual, maybe, but not romantic."

"Meh," I said, "I'd rather have a bike, and GPS, and some kind of portable computer thing. The monk thing never has appealed to me. Much more ninja, be prepared, that's their motto. And the Boy Scouts. Anyway, things just take up too much space, and I haven't watched many of these movies or read any of these books in a while. Or ever, in some cases. And a lot, I read or watched once, then that was it. Movies don't hold much interest for me lately, at least as a solo thing."
"Wait, are we still talking about pornography here? I wasn't paying attention."

"One thing I'll give the Catholics, sloth is pretty bad. Not always, but overdone, oh yeah. Keeps things from getting done. What you need is applied laziness. Well, what I need. So what I need is something else that I need to feel I need to do, so I can put that off by cleaning and getting rid of crap. People usually only clean to avoid doing something else."

"So when will that happen? And are you going to get rid of Voltron?"

"Hell no. Voltron's the defender of the universe. He stays. But I can probably cull at least a third of the books. Just gotta sit down and look through things and ask myself 'Do I want this badly enough to keep it if I only had X space?' and then the stuff that's not, I give to friends, family, or the library or something. Maybe sell to a used bookstore."

The buddha turned and looked at me. "Why am I even here? This is your monologue, there's no questions or anything. And who do you think will be interested in any of this?"

I shrugged. "Probably nobody, though they might all leap t me and try and get me to give them the stuff I'm getting rid of. Few people would turn down loot."


Previously, on X-Men:
Stories from the Rabbit Hole
Stories from the Rabbit Hole, Part 2
There's a Buddha on My Bed
A Discussion of Procrastination and Buddhism
Buddhablog
Haven't Seen Him in a While
The Illusion of Pain

Profile

forsyth: (Default)
Forsyth

May 2018

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
202122 23242526
2728293031  

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 21st, 2025 08:08 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios